April 28, 2009
NOT A CHILD
A great editorial by a soldier in Afghanistan:
(emphasis mine)
The "sons and daughters" argument has always bugged me too.
When I met my husband nearly ten years ago, he was still a teenager. But he had more responsibility than any of the rest of us in college. Stayed up until midnight watching TV? You can skip class, but you can't skip PT. At 19, he managed his life far better than most. And by the time he returned from Iraq at 25, he was a full-fledged man, a man who had been responsible for the safety and lives of 15 other soldiers.
He is not, and never was, a child who needs protecting. He doesn't need concerned citizens to treat him like a dupe or rube and decide what's best for him and where he should direct his energies. He wants to direct them at the Middle East, and if you "bring him home," he will try to find another way to get there somehow.
He is your sword and your shield. And he is a man.
In
a column, Mr. Putney has again raised the debate about the sacrifice of
America's "sons and daughters" in uniform. Some have argued that we
must continue the fight to honor their memory "so that they have not
died in vain." Others argue we must stop the wars to save soldiers from
this fate. I think an essential understanding of what motivates those
of us in uniform is missing in this debate.
We are not your sons and daughters, whom you must protect and defend. We are your sword and your shield. We are men and women who volunteer to place our lives on the line so you do not have to. We do not decide when or where we will be sent. We go. You are our advocates, not our parents.
[...]
I know my life is in the hands of others because I choose for it to be that way. I am not your daughter, a child who must be guided. I have made my choice and pledge my honor to it. I will thank you to remember that because we serve our nation, none of us dies in vain, regardless of the cause; end of debate.
We are not your sons and daughters, whom you must protect and defend. We are your sword and your shield. We are men and women who volunteer to place our lives on the line so you do not have to. We do not decide when or where we will be sent. We go. You are our advocates, not our parents.
[...]
I know my life is in the hands of others because I choose for it to be that way. I am not your daughter, a child who must be guided. I have made my choice and pledge my honor to it. I will thank you to remember that because we serve our nation, none of us dies in vain, regardless of the cause; end of debate.
(emphasis mine)
The "sons and daughters" argument has always bugged me too.
When I met my husband nearly ten years ago, he was still a teenager. But he had more responsibility than any of the rest of us in college. Stayed up until midnight watching TV? You can skip class, but you can't skip PT. At 19, he managed his life far better than most. And by the time he returned from Iraq at 25, he was a full-fledged man, a man who had been responsible for the safety and lives of 15 other soldiers.
He is not, and never was, a child who needs protecting. He doesn't need concerned citizens to treat him like a dupe or rube and decide what's best for him and where he should direct his energies. He wants to direct them at the Middle East, and if you "bring him home," he will try to find another way to get there somehow.
He is your sword and your shield. And he is a man.
Posted by: Sarah at
01:52 PM
| Comments (3)
| Add Comment
Post contains 379 words, total size 3 kb.
April 15, 2009
"MORE FAIR"
Army: UR doin it wrong
(My compliments to Chuck; I totally stole his joke.)
Posted by: Sarah at
12:30 PM
| No Comments
| Add Comment
Post contains 18 words, total size 1 kb.
April 07, 2009
WHEW
In addition to SpouseBUZZ Live and my husband having to work over the weekend, we were also mentally dealing with this: A Lot Can Change In 36 Hours.
Posted by: Sarah at
03:31 AM
| Comments (1)
| Add Comment
Post contains 30 words, total size 1 kb.
<< Page 1 of 1 >>
47kb generated in CPU 0.0454, elapsed 0.1119 seconds.
48 queries taking 0.1049 seconds, 170 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.
48 queries taking 0.1049 seconds, 170 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.