June 03, 2005
SEMANTICS
It's not really possible to count how many words there are in the English language, but it's a lot. And many people agree that English has
more words than most other world languages. Anecdotally, I remember noticing the problem when I was learning French and I wanted to distinguish between jump, hop, and leap; French only has the one jumping verb. There's no distinction in Swedish between winking and blinking, though I'm sure flirters would disagree.
English has plenty of words to describe everything quite accurately, which is why I get so angry when people start conflating the definitions of words. I'm mad that what happened at Abu Ghraib gets labeled as "torture" when we have the word "humiliation" to differentiate the two concepts. The word torture loses its specific meaning when it covers the spectrum, just as jump shouldn't cover both leaps and hops.
I've been especially mad this week over the misuse of the word "gulag" by Amnesty International. "Gulag" is a very specific word used to describe a very specific type of penal system. It is entirely not appropriate for discussing Guantanamo Bay.
The Jawa Report has a well-researched post about what exactly a gulag is. We have plenty of words in the English language to accurately define the differences between the gulag and Gitmo; let's use them.
Posted by: Sarah at
03:21 AM
| Comments (2)
| Add Comment
Post contains 223 words, total size 1 kb.
1
Torture is a semantically valid term. They were physically abusing individuals to try to get them to reveal information. The photos show people bleeding whose legs were torn open by dogs, who were hung by their wrists with wire for extended periods, and other extreme physical abuse. They physically abused to the point that some died. If you want to say that's not torture, and just humiliation, then the word torture no longer has any meaning. You can't humiliate someone to death.
Posted by: VOT at June 08, 2005 01:37 AM (BUIek)
2
This is a debater's trick - you are trying to distract from the point. Amnesty International criticized the United States for holding prisoners without due process and torturing them, and they have the evidence on their side. Only someone wilfully deluding themselves could deny that this is happening.
So what do you do? You accuse Amnesty International of poor word choice. Your contribution to the debate is a piece criticizing Amnesty for the inappropriate use of the term 'Gulag'. Plainly you know you are in a bad spot and are trying to sneak out.
Posted by: Mr. Silly at June 09, 2005 01:04 AM (BUIek)
Hide Comments
| Add Comment
June 02, 2005
SIGH
Amritas
points to an article about "a Los Angeles school board proposal to require all high school students to take college prep courses." One paragraph caught my eye:
Campbell pointed out that some of the students excel in the school's culinary and performing arts classes. But because most of those classes don't qualify as college prep courses, she worries that students will miss out on those subjects.
I missed out on several things in my high school because I was taking college prep. I sure would have benefitted more from typing and computer classes than chemistry! We didn't have culinary classes, but I would've liked to take one.
Know what I do now that I'm an Army wife with two degrees? Cook and type.
I have a friend here on post who quit college when she decided to get married. While her husband was in Basic and AIT, she went to cosmetology school. She makes way more money cutting hair in her home than I did teaching college English. She has a skill that's marketable no matter where she moves, while I'm stuck because apparently I need a PhD to do what I want to do. It wouldn't even have to be in anything related to teaching college English; I just have to have the piece of paper that says I studied something.
So I'm a housewife who cooks and types instead.
I guess it suits me just fine though. If I had it to do all over again, I would've studied mechanical engineering like my dad. I always loved physics. But at least the way things are now, I'm not too bummed to be locked out of a job that only paid me $800 per month in a system that was extremely frustrating. Moreover, I don't necessarily think that Army wifeing and careers go hand in hand. My first loyalty is to the military and my second is to my own job prospects. Not surprisingly, being an out-of-work professor fits easily with our PCS rotation
Posted by: Sarah at
05:46 AM
| Comments (3)
| Add Comment
Post contains 339 words, total size 2 kb.
1
I can't help but smile at this entry
I tease the husband, frequently, that I should just fly back home long enough to learn how to cut hair, and then move back here. You are right, it is much more marketable than the degrees and experience that either of us possess. I still love hearing back from potential employers that my "education and experience are impressive," but that there is "nothing available at this time." Ahh, well. One day, perhaps.
Posted by: Susan R at June 02, 2005 09:29 AM (wtjWR)
2
While I was at DLI learning Russian for the Nat'l Guard, my wife took the Army Family Team Building I course... and then the rest of the courses. And then the instructor course. And then the master instructor course. She's probably more employable than I am now, and it didn't cost her a dime (or require an 8 year commitment).
Posted by: Sig at June 02, 2005 07:07 PM (6CDne)
3
There's nothing stopping you from going back to school *grin* just couldn't resist! I originally went to school and became a nurse... the hours suck pond water and (I don't care what anyone says...) the pay ain't that great either.
So, when I was 29 and my youngest entered kindergarten, I went back to school - it took me 5 years to do about 3 years worth of work, but I got my degree in Computer Science. It was well worth it. Now I'm considering going back for a Masters... although I need breaks, and it's been about 11 years since I got my CS degree, I really enjoy school and learning new stuff. So, think about it - might be worth your time and effort. And you'll have all the humanities stuff out of the way!
Posted by: Teresa at June 03, 2005 03:51 PM (nAfYo)
Hide Comments
| Add Comment
SAD
One of the most depressing blogs out there is Babalu Blog. I swear every time I go there, I feel like crying, and today is no exception. Val Prieto got to talk with a
Cuban who's visiting the US. Commenter Kathleen summed up how I too felt after reading this story: "All this time we've been saying how fidel has ruined Cuba, turned it to shit. The truth of it makes me weep. I can't think of a word in English, or Espanol that expresses how much I'd like to see castro gone. What can we say to this visitor? Yes, we know what has happened to your country, how much your people have suffered. Sorry, the world just doesn't care. Sometimes I'm truly ashamed to be human."
Posted by: Sarah at
03:59 AM
| No Comments
| Add Comment
Post contains 130 words, total size 1 kb.
49kb generated in CPU 0.0139, elapsed 0.0895 seconds.
48 queries taking 0.0806 seconds, 174 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.